comparison of dell vostro versus optiplex
Cracking open the mini-tower Optiplex, we find Dell has gone to great measures to insure a whisper quiet
PC, and a very clean layout. The Optiplex has a large 120mm cooling fan, which draws cool air from the front of the case, blowing
cool air over a massive Heat Pipe style CPU cooling assembly. Heat pipes in general are much more
efficient and quiet than direct contact air cooling fans mounted directly on CPU's. The hard drives are located
at the bottom of the tower case, so the weight of the drives places the center of gravity low, towards the
base. Also the drives are modular, meaning they can be slid in and out without screws (the case also features
a screwless quick release lever, for quick replacement of parts and ease of servicing.
Here is a closeup view of the Optiplex Heat Pipe Cooling assembly, for keeping the Intel Processor
cool.
Dell Vostro 400: Definitely an economy class PC. No quick release levers, accessing the case required a
phillips screwdriver, I found the sheet metal on the Vostro case ultra thin! This keeps the case lightweight and
keeps costs down. The owner should be cautious when resealing the lid, excessive force may bend the lid!
A cheaper active heatsink is used instead of heat pipes. We see a bit of a more wiring mess, typical of some
entry level consumer PCs. Note the unusual location of the hard drive; it's mounted midpoint on the
leftmost side of the case. Do not allow the dog to tip over the tower case, as that will send quite a bit of
physical shock to the hard drive. If that hard drive's spinning, that could
cause a head crash. Inconspicuously absent from both this system board and the Inspiron 530 (below)
are PATA IDE connections.Dell Inspiron 530 (twin of the Vostro 200)
The Inspiron 530 is a twin of the Vostro 200, as you can see, the layout is identical.This Inspiron 530 comes with a Bestec OEM 300 Watt Power Supply. PCNS has seen numerous failures with Bestec power supplies with E-Machines and HP desktop PC's.
The power supply connector is a standard 24 pin jack. Users on Newegg.com and on Dellcommunity have
reported generic beefier power supplies will work in this Inspiron.
As previously noted, this Inspiron 530 system board has no PATA (EIDE) ports, however there's a floppy disk
port. This photo shows the SATA DVD Writer. Below, you see the rear panel connectors. Note the
absence of the old style Parallel and Serial port, also notice the old style round PS2 Mouse/Keyboard
connectors are missing. This Dell takes ONLY USB Keyboards and Mice. The Network adapter
is a 10/100 megabit. Compare this to the Optiplex, which has a 10/100/1000 (gigabit) wired
Ethernet interface.
We're talking economy class ! See below, for the front panel USB and memory card readers.
Here's a closeup shot of the CPU and Chassis fan. Again, economy class, but it does get the
job done.If there was any general conclusion, the overwhelming thought I have is "you get what you pay for."